Steel buildings have become more popular than ever before. Not only are they very durable, but they can also be built much more quickly than concrete buildings. There are two types of steel buildings often used for different purposes. These include clear span and multi-span steel buildings. However, people generally debate the merits of clear-span vs multi-span steel buildings.
Many prefer clear-span steel buildings because they offer more space. Additionally, their maintenance and ease of cleaning are excellent. However, opinions favor multi-span steel buildings for their cost-effectiveness. In this article, I will compare these two steel building types in detail. So, let’s get started.
What is a Clear-Span Steel Building?
Clear-span steel buildings have no interior columns. This means there is more space inside the buildings. This space increases their functionality, especially when used for warehouses or storage sites. The space under the roof is unobstructed, making these buildings look aesthetically appealing.
Interestingly, some people believe these open space buildings don’t use columns at all. This is wrong as the columns are present in these buildings. These columns are installed along the side walls to improve weight distribution. However, there are no columns inside the buildings. Steel trusses and frames make up the major portion of these buildings.
Although columns are fewer in number, they are of the highest strength and robustness. Their cost is generally higher than that of regular columns used in multi-span steel buildings. As I said above, clear-span steel buildings offer more space. So you can drive your vehicles inside these buildings. In fact, aircraft hangars are generally made as clear-span steel buildings.
What is a Multi-Span Steel Building?
Multi-span steel buildings are the opposite of clear-span buildings. They consist of many steel columns within the buildings. These columns distribute the load, making the buildings stronger and more durable. However, the space inside a multi-span steel building is lower than that in a clear-span steel building.
Generally, multiple rows of columns are present inside, along with columns going along the sidewalls. The bigger multi-span steel buildings have more columns and vice versa. Due to the presence of these columns, the internal space of these buildings is more partitioned. These columns then connect to the steel beams to make the skeleton of these buildings.
It is worth noting that the beams and columns used in these steel buildings are slightly lighter. Why? The reason is that multiple columns distribute the load efficiently. This means each beam faces fewer loads, and there is no need to use thicker beams. These lighter beams are less expensive, reducing costs for multi-span buildings. When it comes to functionality, you get less space inside, which could be a drawback.
Differences Between Clear-Span and Multi-Span Steel Buildings
Selection between clear-span and multi-span steel buildings can be difficult. One can easily get confused as both offer unique pros and cons. In the upcoming section, I will discuss the differences between these two steel buildings. Understanding this analysis and its differences will help you decide which steel building is best for you.
1- Interior Columns & Space Layout
Clear-span steel buildings don’t have interior columns. As a result, there is more unobstructed space inside that can be utilized. You can use this space, too, and enjoy the flexible layout. The unobstructed space allows for easier movement and better organization. In contrast, multi-span steel buildings have rows of columns. These rows create partitions and spans within the buildings and utilize some of the spaces. Therefore, these multi-span buildings are not the best if you want a flexible layout. Your movements inside the buildings would be easier.
2- Flexibility & Aesthetic Appeal
I consider a clear-span steel building a better option for flexibility and aesthetic appeal. The reason is that these buildings have more space inside. There are no columns or restrictions that could hinder the view. You get more space inside and can customize it to your preferred layout. The open area gives these buildings a more spacious feeling. As a result, these buildings look more refined and aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand, multi-span steel buildings have less space inside due to rows of columns. These columns create spans and sections inside which affect their visual appeal.
3- Durability & Functionality
Multi-span steel buildings are the best option for durability. Why? This is because these buildings consist of multiple columns. This column goes along the side wall as well as inside the buildings. These multiple columns distribute the load better. As a result, less stress is put on the walls and other components of the buildings.
This makes multi-span structures a bit more durable than clear-span structures. Remember, clear-span buildings have fewer columns, which is a drawback. Weight distribution in these buildings is uneven, which could affect their durability. However, clear-span buildings stand out for their functionality. They offer more space for easier storage.
Quick Highlight: Cleaning clear-span steel buildings is easier than cleaning multi-span buildings. Better ease of cleaning helps in maintaining these buildings. On the other hand, multi-span buildings are less user-friendly for cleaning and maintenance. Multiple obstructions from interior columns hinder the movement of cleaners.
4- Installation Time & Foundation Cost
Clear-span steel buildings can be installed quickly. Why? The reason is that these buildings consist of fewer columns. This means you will only need to install the outer column along the side walls. There is no need to install an internal column, which requires right alignment. This alignment process can be time-consuming, resulting in higher installation costs.
On the other hand, multi-span buildings require more columns inside and along the sidewalls. These columns and their alignment take more time. This results in higher installation time in multi-span buildings. When it comes to foundation costs, clear-span buildings are more expensive than their counterparts. Their foundations require concrete and steel reinforcement, requiring deeper digging into the ground.
In clear-span buildings, all the loads of the building are concentrated on the columns present along the side walls. Therefore, the foundation for these columns must be very strong. You’ll need to use more concrete, more steel reinforcement, and deeper digging to create strong foundations. Multi-span steel buildings use more columns, which distribute the loads easily. So, only regular concrete foundations work well for multi-span steel buildings. This results in lower foundation costs in these steel buildings.
5- Load Distribution & Maximum Width Capability
Clear-span steel buildings are not a good option for load distribution. As discussed above, the load from the roof and other structures is transferred to the outer column. These columns are fewer in number and are present along the sidewalls. Therefore, these buildings require strong edge supports and foundations.
Clear-span steel buildings have specific size or width limitations. On the other hand, multi-span steel buildings offer excellent load distributions. The reason is that these buildings have more columns, which puts greater stress on each structure. These multi-span steel buildings have no width limitations. You can make as wide buildings as you want.
6- Expansion Flexibility & Material Usage
Clear-span steel buildings are very compromised in terms of expansion flexibility. Additionally, material use is high in these buildings. The reason is that these steel buildings lack columns to evenly distribute the load. As a result, more stress is put on the beams and other components. Therefore, these components are made more robust by using more steel.
This higher steel use increases material costs for these steel buildings. Conversely, multi-span buildings can be expanded easily. How? As you know, these buildings have internal columns. When expanding, you add more columns and beams, enabling the building to expand effortlessly. Material usage is also lower in a multi-span steel building than in a clear-span building.
7- Design Freedom & Crane Compatibility
Clear-span steel buildings are excellent options for creating a sense of freedom. As I said above, these buildings offer more space inside as there are no columns. This more space allows you to design the layout easily. In other words, you get more space to make a warehouse, showroom, and anything else as per your needs.
Multi-span buildings create obstructed spaces, which is less ideal for design freedom. Crane compatibility is another factor that differentiates these two buildings. Multi-span buildings are a better option for crane compatibility. The reason is that these have more columns, which support the overhead crane system’s weight. Lifting and transporting loads inside the building becomes easiest with crane compatibility.
5- Construction Cost & Ideal Use Case
Clear-span steel buildings are more costly than multi-span buildings. This is very confusing, as people believe that multi-span designs use more columns and are therefore expensive. However, the reality is different: more steel is used in the clear-span building. Actually, clear-span steel buildings require a stronger foundation.
You’ll have to add more concrete and steel bars to these foundations. Additionally, columns and beams will be very robust and use more materials. These factors increase the construction costs of clear-span steel buildings. On the other hand, the foundation of multi-span buildings doesn’t involve very deep digging.
Additionally, their columns and beams require fewer materials because they are numerous. Despite being less robust, these higher column counts ensure decent durability. For ideal use cases, clear-span steel buildings are preferred when you need more space. On the other hand, multi-span steel buildings are suitable for tight budgets.
Below is the table showing a comparison of the best uses of these two steel buildings:
| Clear-Span Steel Buildings | Multi-Span Steel Buildings |
|---|---|
| Sports halls | Factories or manufacturing plants |
| Aircraft hangars | Large warehouses |
| Exhibition & trade centers | Production lines with cranes |
| Shopping showrooms (open layout) | Logistics and distribution centers |
| Event or wedding halls | Power plants / heavy industries |
| Indoor arenas | Storage facilities for heavy goods |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for resale value, a clear or a multi-span building?
Clear-span steel buildings retain their resale value better. People generally prefer this type of steel building as it offers more interior space. It can be used to build warehouses and can be redesigned to accommodate additional space. People seem willing to pay more for a clear-span than for a multi-span steel building.
Is it possible to remove a column from a Multi-Span building later?
No. Once a multi-span building is made, it is not possible to remove any column. If you do so, it would significantly affect the building’s strength. In some cases, the roof can even sag, and buildings may collapse.
Which building type is more expensive: a clear-span or a multi-span building?
Clear-span steel buildings are more expensive than their counterparts. The reason is that these buildings require a robust foundation with deep footings. More concrete and steel bars are used in these foundations. Additionally, these steel buildings require a large amount of steel, which increases costs.
Conclusion
Still wondering about which of these two steel buildings is right for your project? It depends on your preferences and what you actually need. If you prefer more space, a refined visual appeal, and design freedom, you should choose a clear-span building. Although the price of these buildings would be higher, they will offer better value.
However, if you have a tight budget, choosing a multi-span steel building makes sense. In these buildings, you get less space, but you can expand the building as per your needs. Remember, these buildings also offer excellent durability and load distribution. Better load distribution means the building will remain in good shape for years, even when exposed to harsh conditions.
